Open Farm Review: Ethically Raised & Sourced Pet Food

*Some of the links in this post are affiliate links, meaning that I will earn a commission if you make a purchase. The cost to you is not affected. I only recommend products that I think you will find useful. I appreciate your support in this manner.*

One of the things I struggled with as a vegetarian was whether I should put my dog Mimi on a vegetarian diet to go along with my ethical choices. I researched this a lot and the opinions are so varied that I could not make a decision. There are people who claim that their dogs thrived on a vegan/vegetarian diet, and there are others who call it unnatural because a dogs’ natural instinct is to eat meat.

I am of the belief that it is unethical to not feed a dog meat. Dogs are descendants of wolves, and wolves are carnivores. It is ingrained in their being to eat meat. If a pack of domesticated dogs were out in the wild and spotted a dead animal they would probably eat it. It’s their natural behavior.

Regardless of the ethics and science behind it, ultimately I know that Mimi would not be happy as a vegetarian. My dog makes a particular happy face when she smells meat. I can’t imagine taking that away from her just to satisfy my own personal beliefs. But as a vegetarian, it just didn’t sit right with me that each time I bought dog food I was supporting the cruel treatment of farm animals in factory farms.

Well, as I was doing research for another post, I ran across a Canadian dog food company called Open Farm. I was jumping for joy when I found this company! Here’s what makes Open Farm different from all other pet food brands:

  • All meat and poultry are sourced from family farms (not factory farms) that are Certified Humane. These farms are held to high animal welfare standards and must pass routine audits in order to maintain the certification. Read more about Certified Humane here.
  • All fish are ocean caught. They do not use fish that were raised in aquafarms.
  • They do not use any meat or poultry meals. Meals are made in large batches and are made of animal by-product that may contain bones and meat from dead and disabled animals. Instead, they use an ocean caught fish meal that is produced in small batches. This way they can guarantee that the fish were naturally raised and not fed hormones or antibiotics.
  • They do not test on animals. Yes, some pet food brands test on animals.
  • Vegetables and fruits are non-GMO, and approximately 90% are grown near their manufacturing plant in Minnesota or a neighboring state.
  • It is formulated for all life stages, meaning that it’s suitable for puppies, adults, and seniors.
  • And last but not least, it is 100% grain-free, which is ideal for pets like Mimi that suffer from allergies.

Seems like Mimi’s needs as well as my concerns are met! I had only 1 more question concerning the size of the kibble. Mimi is a Miniature Pinscher & Chihuahua mix with a small snout and needs the kibble to be small. I emailed Open Farm about it and they wrote back the next day:

Thank you for reaching out and showing an interest in Open Farm! Our kibble is in the smaller side, about 1 cm x 1 cm and a bit flat. I also sometimes recommend if your dog is small and has an issue with kibble, to add water or broth to the food to soften it up.

That same day I went to the store and bought Open Farm Grain-Free Homestead Turkey & Chicken Recipe. Several other recipes are available for both cats and dogs.

OPEN FARM CERTIFIED HUMANE DOG FOOD

Open Farm is not carried at big chain stores, and I’m lucky to have a small boutique near me that carries it. If you live in South Florida please check out Auggie’s Doggies in Fort Lauderdale. They carry a very large selection of pet foods and supplies that you won’t find anywhere else, and they do not carry any Chinese made products.

The first 5 ingredients are humanely farmed turkey, humanely farmed chicken, ocean caught whitefish meal, russet potatoes, and garbanzo beans (chickpeas). I bring this up because we’ve all seen the commercials comparing the first 5 ingredients in leading versus supermarket pet food brands. As you see there are no by-products added. You can see all the ingredients here.

The food has a strong fishy smell. The smell smacked me in the face when I first opened the bag, and I was concerned that my kitchen would smell like fish which is where I keep Mimi’s food. But the smell is only noticeable if the food is near your nose.

The kibble size turned out to not be a problem at all. It’s actually a bit smaller that the kibble I was feeding her before which was made specifically for small breeds.

OPEN FARM DOG FOOD KIBBLE SIZE COMPARISON

Price wise, the 12lb bag costs about $10 more than similar products from Blue Buffalo and Wellness. There is a price to pay for humane until it becomes the norm. A 4.5lb bag is available if you don’t want to commit to a 12lb or 24lb right away.

If there are no retailers near you, you can buy Open Farm from Amazon.

I recommend Open Farm to anyone who’s concerned about animal welfare. Honestly, what is the point of worrying about where your food comes from if you won’t hold your pets food to the same standards?

This food is also ideal for vegans and vegetarians who are not comfortable feeding their pets a vegan or vegetarian diet.

Mimi has been eating Open Farm food for over a month and so far she is enjoying it. Her cousins seem to like it as well because every time they come visit they eat it all up. They will be making the switch soon.

Most importantly, her allergies have finally alleviated. Although the calming of her allergies would likely be achieved with any grain-free food, the fact that Open Farm is Certified Humane keeps my vegetarian conscious at ease.

Sorry, I’ve decided to turn off comments

The number of comments and emails that I receive are too much to handle, so I’ve decided to centralize all communication to email only. Just scroll down to “contact me”, and feel free to send me any comments, questions, complaints, or concerns 🙂

7 Responses
  • AllEnergy
    January 10, 2018

    I’m vegan and struggling with what I am feeding my dogs and cats. I feed raw freeze dried Stella and Chewy brand and every time I make their bowls it begins… the sadness of how these freeze dried animal parts came to be. My questions: Are you still using Open Farm? Have there been any recalls? Are your dogs still healthy and happy? Just checking in …thank you so much for this article and for caring about animals XO

    • Tammy @ GFV
      January 11, 2018

      I understand your dilemma, which is why I decided to feed my dogs Open Farm and still do. They are very happy and healthy. One of them has allergies and she has been scratching a lot less since I started feeding her Open Farm almost 2 years ago. There have not been any recalls. You can sign up for the Dog Advisor newsletter and they will inform you of any recalls… https://www.dogfoodadvisor.com/dog-food-reviews/open-farm-dog-food/

      Thanks so much for reading and for also caring about animals 🙂

  • Veganimal
    August 14, 2017

    Loved this post! I was in the same exact predicament and went on a frantic search for a dog food that holds to my standards. As much as I love all animals, am a vegan, and a huge animal activist, I can’t bring myself to deprive my dogs of meat they were created to eat. They have the proper teeth to eat meat, we don’t. Looks like this is the next best thing. Thanks again for this post! Bought my first bag of Open Farm and testing it out!

    • Tammy @ GFV
      August 15, 2017

      I am glad that you found it helpful! And happy to know that I’m not the only veggie that finds vegan or vegetarian pets unnatural, but to each it’s own 🙂 Let me know how your dogs like it!

  • GingerBean
    May 18, 2017

    This sounds amazing– I wish it wasn’t so expensive!!! 🙁 We’d surely go broke in no time with our animals! haha. Did you find any other brands that were *better* out there but not necessarily the best of the *best* that you might suggest??

    • Tammy @ GFV
      May 20, 2017

      It really is a great food, but you’re right it is pricey! Luckily my sister and I split the cost and share it so it doesn’t hurt our pockets too much. We both have small dogs so it lasts a long time.

      You should try Zignature. I saw a 27lb bag for $54 on Amazon! That’s a great deal! They have really good reviews too, so I wouldn’t say that it is of lower quality. Let me know how it goes if you decide to try it!

      • GingerBean
        May 22, 2017

        I’ll definitely look into it, thanks! 🙂